A holiday braise

Dave's Holiday Pot Roast

Chuck roast cut into cubes, seared hard, and braised low and slow in red wine with thick-cut bacon, mushrooms and onions, finished with a gravy that coats the spoon.

Serves 6 About 3 to 3 1/2 hours 325°F oven
Scale it to your roast

Ingredients for your roast

Weigh your chuck roast, or read the weight off the label, and enter it below. Every amount on this page resizes to match and rounds to sizes you can measure. Then print it or save it as a PDF to take into the kitchen.

  1. 1Weigh the roast
  2. 2Enter the weight
  3. 3Print or save the recipe
Serves about 6
Scale 1.00x the 3 lb recipe
Oven 325°F
Usually done in 3 hours
Excel calculator
AmountIngredient

UK and metric amounts use the standard 15 ml tablespoon and 5 ml teaspoon. Amounts scale in a straight line from the 3 lb recipe, so for a much bigger batch, taste the seasoning near the end and adjust.

Method

You'll need a heavy Dutch oven with a lid. Heat the oven to 325°F before you start. Treat this recipe as a guide. Every roast, pot and oven behaves a little differently, so keep an eye on two things as it cooks: the liquid level and the beef. The times and amounts here get you close, and your eyes and a fork do the rest.

Raw chuck roast and bacon on a maple end-grain chopping block, with onions, carrots, mushrooms, red wine and small bowls of dried herbs on a granite counter

Prep the beef and bacon

Trim the thick outer fat cap off the chuck. Chuck is already well marbled, so you lose nothing by taking off the heavy stuff. Cut the beef into 2-inch cubes and pat them dry with paper towels.

Cut the bacon into lardons, short batons about 1/4 to 1/2 inch thick. Coarsely chop the onions and cut the carrots into chunks.

Butcher-cut slab bacon is best. If you can't get it, buy the thickest bacon at the grocery store.

Par-cooked bacon lardons draining on paper towels next to a small dish of poured-off bacon fat, with a red Dutch oven on the stove

Par-cook the bacon

Cook the lardons in the Dutch oven over medium heat until they're lightly browned and just crisp. Lift them out onto a paper-towel-lined plate.

Pour off most of the fat, leaving about 2 tbsp in the pot. That's enough for flavor and for searing. The chuck renders plenty of its own fat during the braise.

Beef cubes searing in a red Dutch oven on a gas burner, with a plate of browned cubes and more raw cubes on the chopping block

Flour and sear the beef

Season the cubes lightly with pepper, then toss them in 2 tbsp of flour (half of the total) until they're evenly dusted. Shake off the excess.

Sear over medium-high heat in small batches until every side has a deep brown crust. Move each batch to a plate.

Leave space between the cubes. A crowded pot steams the meat grey instead of browning it.

Chopped onions softening in red wine in the red Dutch oven, with a wooden spoon across the rim and an open bottle of wine nearby

Soften the onions, add the flour and wine

Lower the heat to medium and cook the chopped onions in the same pot until soft and lightly golden, about 6 to 8 minutes.

There should still be a thin film of bacon fat in the pot. If it looks dry, add 1 tablespoon of butter. Sprinkle the other 2 tbsp of flour over the onions and stir for a minute or two, until it smells toasty and you can't see any dry flour. This small roux is what thickens the gravy over the long braise, so you shouldn't need cornstarch at the end.

Pour in the red wine and scrape the browned bits off the bottom with a wooden spoon. Those bits are where most of the flavor in the gravy comes from.

Seared beef, bacon, onions and mushrooms in wine and broth in the red Dutch oven, with chopped carrots waiting on the chopping block

Build the pot and braise

Add the broth, Worcestershire, Maggi, rosemary, thyme, sage, garlic powder, onion powder and the rest of the pepper. Return the beef with its juices, the bacon and the mushrooms.

The liquid should come just to the top of the meat without covering it. Bring it to a simmer on the stove, cover, and move the pot to a rack in the lower third of the 325°F oven.

If your lid doesn't fit snugly, lay a sheet of foil over the pot and press the lid down on top of it so less steam escapes. Take the foil off when you set the lid ajar at the end.

After about 1 1/2 hours, stir in the carrots. Start checking the beef at 2 1/2 hours. It's done when a cube shreds with gentle pressure from a fork, usually by 3 hours.

Each time you check the beef, give the pot a stir so nothing catches on the bottom, and check the liquid too. The lid keeps most of it in, but over a long braise some cooks off. If it has dropped below about halfway up the meat, add hot broth from the extra you set aside until it's back to the top of the meat.

The pot should barely simmer. If it's bubbling hard when you lift the lid, turn the oven down to 300°F. A hard boil makes the meat tough and dry however long it cooks.

If a cube is still firm or chewy, it isn't done. The connective tissue hasn't melted yet, so give it another 20 to 30 minutes and check again. Don't turn the heat up to hurry it.

When the beef is tender, look at the gravy. If it already coats a spoon, it's done. If it's thin, set the lid ajar for 20 to 30 minutes so it reduces. This is the part that needs some babysitting. The liquid drops faster with the lid open, so check every 10 minutes, give it a stir, and take the pot out once the gravy coats a spoon, before it gets too thick.

A white bowl of braised beef with bacon, carrots and mushrooms in thick red wine gravy, garnished with rosemary and parsley, on a granite counter

Finish the gravy and serve

Spoon off the fat that has risen to the top before you judge the gravy, because a layer of fat makes it look thinner than it is. You're after a gravy a step past nappe: it coats the back of a spoon and holds a clean line when you run a finger through it, but it isn't as heavy as gravy for mashed potatoes.

If it's too thick, stir in a few tablespoons of the hot broth you set aside until it loosens.

If it's still thin, the first fix is time: lift the beef and vegetables out with a slotted spoon into a covered bowl and simmer the liquid uncovered on the stove for 10 to 20 minutes, stirring, until it coats a spoon. Then return the beef and vegetables.

Cornstarch is the last resort. If you need it, bring the liquid to a boil, then stir 1 tbsp of cornstarch into 2 tbsp of cold water. Whisk half of it into the boiling liquid and keep it boiling, stirring the whole time, for about a minute, until it turns glossy and thickens. Check, and add more slurry only if it needs it. Then return the beef and vegetables to the pot.

Cornstarch won't thicken until the liquid boils. With the meat and vegetables still in the pot, it's very hard to get the gravy hot enough and stir it evenly, which is why they come out first.

Taste, and only then add salt. Bacon, Maggi and Worcestershire all bring plenty. Garnish each bowl with a small sprig of fresh rosemary and some chopped flat-leaf parsley.

Notes from the kitchen

What makes it great

Follow any recipe word for word and it can come out a little wet one time and a little dry the next. What makes this one great is paying attention as it cooks: check the liquid, test a cube with a fork, seal a loose lid with foil, and stay close for the last half hour.

Why flour first, cornstarch only as a backup

Flour, on the beef and stirred into the onions, thickens slowly and holds up through a long, hot braise. Cornstarch breaks down over hours of heat and acid from the wine, so if the gravy needs it at all, it goes in at the end, into boiling liquid.

About the salt

Maggi is soy-based and full sodium, and it contains MSG, which is part of why it adds so much savory depth. Between it, the Worcestershire and the bacon, many batches need little or no added salt.

The wine

Use a red you'd drink. Merlot is the house choice. Cabernet Sauvignon works too and gives a slightly firmer, more tannic sauce.

The mushrooms

They stay whole so anyone who doesn't like them can pick them out. Leave them in the pot anyway, because they add a lot of savory flavor.

David Soden
From Dave's kitchen
David Soden

Happy holidays

Every roast you buy is a different size. Weigh it, enter the number, and print a recipe made for that roast.

Back to the calculator